In missouri, where a defendant convicted of selling. Mar 16, 2014 sacramento, ca senator holly mitchell dlos angeles introduced senate bill 1010 to equalize the penalties for crack cocaine to the current penalties for powder cocaine. Basically, for sentencing purposes in the federal system, the relevant statute 21 u. Both would end the disparity between powder and crack cocaine sentences. The new law significantly reduces the cocaine sentencing quantity disparity from 100 to 1 to 18 to 1 by raising the quantity of crack cocaine necessary to trigger the five and tenyear mandatory minimum sentences first set in 1986. Growing support in white house and congress to address crack. How an early biden crime bill created the sentencing disparity for. First step act applies the fair sentencing act retroactively. Unless one assumes the penalties for powder cocaine are vastly too low, then the farhigher penalties for crack are at odds with the seriousness of the offense. A person convicted of a first offense of possessing five grams of crack had to be sentenced to five years in federal prison. The disparity started in the 1980s, when crack cocaine started to ravish urban black communities in america.
Similarly, those carrying ten grams of crack cocaine. Federal crack cocaine sentencing the sentencing project. The 1986 anti drug abuse act mandated a minimum sentence of five years without parole for possession of 5 grams of crack cocaine while it mandated the same penalty for possession of 500 grams of. A person convicted of fifty or even 499 grams of powder cocaine would face a maximum penalty of one year in prison. This guide highlights the incredible breadth, depth and reliability of government information on this topic. Hearing before the senate committee on the judiciary, subcommittee on crime and drugs 2009 testimony of judge reggie walton, chair of the judicial conference of the united states when large segments of the. Cracked justice updated 32411 2 sentencing project. Jul 15, 2015 for her final paper, byrd wanted to write about the disparity between crack cocaine and powder cocaine sentences and the disparate effect on african americans and hispanics, but she needed real. The sentencing disparities between crack and cocaine attn.
Connecticut equalized penalties for crack and powder in 2005. Jul 01, 2014 the us sentencing commission provided this analogy in 1997 to support equalizing penalties for crack and powder cocaine. The new form of cocaine was called crack, and by the summer of 1986 it was fueling fears of a drug epidemic. Established by the antidrug abuse acts of 1986 and 1988, the 100to1 ratio relates to the amount of crack versus powder cocaine necessary to trigger mandatory minimum prison sentences meaning that possession of five grams of crack cocaine would mandate the same minimum sentence as 500 grams of powder cocaine. On august 3, 2010, president obama signed into law historic legislation that reduces the twodecadesold sentencing disparity between federal crack and powder cocaine offenses. Apr 26, 2009 the 1986 and 1988 antidrug abuse acts created a disparity in sentencing between two forms of cocaine, crack cocaine and powder, at the federal level even though scientific evidence, including a major study published in the journal of the american medical association, has proven that crack and powder cocaine have similar physiological and. Aug 20, 2019 the sentencing disparity between offenses involving crack cocaine compared to powder cocaine had the effect of imposing longer sentences on africanamerican defendants compared to defendants of other races. That year, national news outlets began reporting inflammatory anecdotes supposedly revealing a crack epidemic. Richard durbin, dil, introduced the fair sentencing act of 2009, which would put an end to over two decades of excessively punitive sentencing policy for crack cocaine offenses. In 2010, there was bipartisan support in congress for reducing the disparity in sentences between crack and powder cocaine, against a backdrop of. Because crack and powder cocaine are two forms of the same drug, there should not be any disparity in sentencing between crack and powder cocaine offenses the only truly fair ratio is 1.
Cocaine and federal sentencing policy iv may 20022002 report. House republicans and democrats are in agreement that u. Jan 20, 2011 lumpkins 20year sentence was mandated by law under unfair and discriminatory u. The powder crack cocaine penalty equalization act of 2009, h. Proposals to eliminate sentencing disparities between.
Crack and cocaine powder sentencing disparities essay. The tide is clearly turning against the failed war on drugs. Under federal sentencing laws adopted in the midst of the crack hysteria of the 1980s, it takes 500 grams of powder cocaine to generate a mandatory minimum fiveyear federal prison sentence, but. Crack cocaine sentences have long been much more harsh than those for powder cocaine. Why are crack cocaine sentences longer than those for.
Now, the ten year sentence is triggered by 280 grams of crack instead of 50. Aug 04, 2010 fox news segment on president obama signing new legislation to reduce the crack powder sentencing disparity. The sentencing disparity between offenses involving crack cocaine compared to powder cocaine had the effect of imposing longer sentences on africanamerican defendants compared to defendants of other races. Durbin introduces bill to end crackpowder sentencing. The federal government sought to crack down on the problem by implementing severe prison sentences for those people caught dealing crack cocaine. The bill that was passed which included the crack powder sentencing disparity did so with the support of the majority of black congresspersons. Critics of the disparity argue that this policy has a racially discriminatory impact on sentencing because. I have seen or received lots of distinct commentary in reaction to senate judiciary committees unanimous vote today to reduce but not eliminate crack powder disparity in federal mandatory sentencing statutes reported here. Senator holly mitchell introduces fair sentencing act to. Bidens current criminal justice agenda would reverse virtually all of his past toughoncrime measures, including mandatory minimum sentences and the remaining crack powder sentencing disparity. An end to crackpowder cocaine sentencing disparity.
C 841 treats one gram of crack cocaine as equivalent to 100 grams of powder cocaine. Brandons law practice is focused on federal criminal defense, federal appeals, federal postconviction relief, federal civil rights litigation, federal administrative law, and the freedom of information act foia. The media mischaracterized crack as more potent, more addictive, and more likely to lead to violence than powder cocaine or other drugs. Brandon sample is an attorney, author, and criminal justice reform activist. Specifically, the penalty for possessing 500g of powder cocaine was comparable to possessing only 5g of crack. Africanamericans now serve virtually as much time in prison for a drug offense 58. What is the chemical difference between crack cocaine and powder cocaine that. Feb 19, 2015 socioeconomically disadvantaged adults are more likely to use crack over powder cocaine, and are thus more likely to be subject to arrest.
A comprehensive examination of the 100to1 crack versus powder cocaine sentencing disparity under which distribution of just 5 grams of crack carries a minimum 5year federal prisonsentence, while distribution of 500 grams of powder cocaine carries the same 5year mandatory minimum sentence. These disparities were enacted into law through the antidrug abuse act of 1986 as part of a wave of raciallytinged media hysteria. In 2010, the sentencing disparity between powder and crack cocaine offenses was only partially rectified through the fair sentencing act. Today states maintain sentencing disparities between crack and powder cocaine offenses. The obama administration endorsed eliminating the crackpowder sentencing disparity during hearings on the issue. Cracking the racial disparity for cocaine sentencing center. Similarly, while sale of 5,000 grams of powder leads to a 10year sentence, only 50 grams of crack trigger the same 10year sentence. A comprehensive examination of the 100to1 crack versus powder cocaine sentencing disparity under which distribution of just 5 grams of crack carries a.
Some 2020 democratic candidate argue that the sentencing disparity between crack cocaine and powder cocaine, which now sits at 18 to 1, should be eliminated entirely. And importantly, the fair sentencing act did not amend the penalties in 21 u. Much of the discrepancy at the federal level is the result of differences in the federal sentencing of drug offenses involving crack and powder cocaine. Criminal division aag breuer testimony re restoring. It takes trafficking in 500 grams of powder cocaine to receive the same sentence as one. Such a change would permit judges to consider the full range of sentencing criteria in all crack cocaine cases, rather than in just the relatively modest number of cases permissible under the current sentencing structure. Thus, an offense for possession with intent to distribute powder cocaine is plainly not a covered offense under the first step act. The quantity distinction has also resulted in a massive sentencing disparity by race, with african americans receiving longer sentences than the mostly white and.
Proposals to eliminate sentencing disparities between crack and. Kenneth lumpkin victim of discriminatory sentencing disparity. Fair sentencing act american civil liberties union. Sentencing commission regarding the powder crack cocaine sentencing disparity and reconsider proposals to amend the law. The difference between crack and cocaine powder cocaine powder is. The disparity in sentences for crack offenses and powder cocaine offenses. Apr 29, 2009 the sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine but also fully accounts for violence, chronic offenders, weapon possession and other aggravating factors associated in individual cases with both crack and powder cocaine trafficking. The controlled substances act established a minimum mandatory sentence of five years for a firsttime trafficking offense involving over five grams of crack, as opposed to 500 grams of powder. When significant numbers of african americans on the. In 2010 congress passed the fair sentencing act, which repealed the mandatory minimum sentence for simple possession and reduced the sentencing disparity from 100.
The united states sentencing commission, the bipartisan body that sets guidelines for federal prison sentences, urged congress to eliminate the sentencing disparity more than a decade ago. Iowa modified the state sentencing disparity in 2003 from 100to1 to 10to1. The stark difference in federal sentencing laws for possession of the two forms of the same drug has more to do with media mythology and political pressure than with public safety and health. The fsa changed this socalled 100toone disparity to a disparity of 18toone. Senate move to close crackpowder cocaine jail disparity. The quantity disparity between crack and powder cocaine moves from 100 to 1 to 18 to 1, reducing a disparity that has been in effect for more than two decades. Supporters of the disparity argue that crack offenses warrant harsher. The disparity in cocaine penalties grew out of the skyrocketing use of. In oklahoma, which maintains a 6to1 quantitybased sentencing disparity, a tenyear mandatory minimum sentence is triggered for five grams of crack cocaine and 28 grams of powder cocaine. Famm supported that reform, the fair sentencing act fsa. Under what is commonly referred to as the 100to1 cocaine sentencing disparity, it takes one hundred times as much powder cocaine as crack cocaine to trigger the federal mandatory minimums. Crack cocaine sentencing policy prison policy initiative. The commission reported in 2004 that revising the crack cocaine thresholds would better reduce the sentencing gap than any other single policy change, and it would dramatically improve the fairness of the federal sentencing. At the time, possession of crack cocaine resulted in penalties 100 times higher than possession of an equal amount of the powdered form.
Aug 05, 2009 supporters of the disparity argue that crack offenses warrant harsher sentencing because it is a uniquely addictive drug and is more associated with violent crime than powder cocaine. This disparity between crack and powder cocaine was driven by fear, instead of by research, of the intensity and perceived dangers of crack cocaine. In august 2010 president barack obama signed the fair sentencing act fsa, historic legislation that reduced the quantitybased sentencing differential between federal crack and powder cocaine convictions that resulted in significant racial disparities and excessive penalties. Sacramento, ca senator holly mitchell dlos angeles introduced senate bill 1010 to equalize the penalties for crack cocaine to the current penalties for powder cocaine. Jan 29, 2019 crack and power cocaine sentencing disparities. Obama administration tells congress to end crackpowder. Data show racial disparity in crack sentencing us news. The quantity distinction has also resulted in a massive sentencing disparity by. The fair sentencing act 2010 reduced sentencing disparities to 18.
Criminal division aag breuer testimony re restoring fairness. The amount of powder cocaine necessary to trigger the sentence is still five kilos. Nov 14, 2018 a 2010 law intended to address the sentencing disparity between crack cocaine offenders and powder cocaine offenders would be applied retroactively covering inmates incarcerated for crack. The adaa created a 100toone ratio between the quantity of crack versus powder cocaine needed to trigger mandatory minimum sentencing. Before 1986, federal sentencing laws treated possession of crack and powder cocaine the same. The fair sentencing act of 2009 would reduce the controversial 100to1 sentencing quantity disparity between crack and powder cocaine by increasing the amount of crack. Congress is urged to remedy the unwarranted racially discriminatory impact of cocaine sentencing by enacting legislation equalizing the penalty structures between crack and powder cocaine, at the current level set for powder cocaine. Obama commutes sentences for 8 in crack cocaine cases. Sentencing commission, the changes to the current penalties for crack cocaine offenses would affect nearly 3,000 defendants a year by reducing their. We believe the structure is especially problematic because a growing number.
Disparity in sentencing for crack vs powder cocaine essay. Senator mitchells bill will correct the groundless disparity in sentencing, probation and asset forfeiture guidelines for possession of crack cocaine for sale versus the same crime involving powder cocaine that has. Assistant majority leader dick durbin dil introduced the fair sentencing act of 2009, a narrowlytailored bill that would eliminate the sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine and increase penalties for the worst offenders. The senate crime and drugs subcommittee will hold a hearing to discuss crack cocaine sentencing. For example, possession of just 5 grams of crack cocaine about a thimble full triggers a five year mandatory minimum sentence. Disparity in sentencing for crack vs powder cocaine. Sentencing commission that show the crack powder disparity. Proposals to eliminate sentencing disparities between crack. Supporters of the disparity argue that crack offenses warrant harsher sentencing because it is a uniquely addictive drug and is more associated with violent crime than powder cocaine. This is often what people are referring to when they mention drug related sentencing disparities. The 1980s war on drug laws created a staggering sentencing disparity for offenses involving crack versus powder cocaine, filling prisons with lowlevel offenders and fueling a raciallycharged debate over fairness and efficacy of federal drug policy for nearly 25 years. Apr 15, 2020 the question presented to us is whether a conspiracy that involves the distribution of 50 or more grams of crack cocaine, which is a covered offense under the act because the penalties for it were modified by the fair sentencing act, remains a covered offense if the conspiracy also charges distribution of powder cocaine, the penalties for. The sentencing commission has also reported that many of the rationales originally relied upon to produce the disparity between powder and crack cocaine are unsupportable, because.
There is no significant chemical differencecrack and powder cocaine are both forms of cocaine. Obama signs law to reduce crack powder sentencing disparity. The legislation also eliminates the mandatory minimum for simple possession of crack cocaine. Crackpowder disparity testimony of wade henderson the. Apr 30, 2009 both would end the disparity between powder and crack cocaine sentences. In 2010, congress passed the fair sentencing act fsa, which reduced the sentencing disparity between offenses for crack and powder cocaine from 100. Proposals to eliminate sentencing disparities between crack and powder cocaine offenses. For instance, there are federal guidelines ensuring that people who get caught with crack are sentenced more harshly than those who are caught with powder cocaine. Crack and cocaine powder sentencing disparities essay sample.
The senate crime and drugs subcommittee will hold a hearing to discuss crack cocaine sentencing on wednesday, april 29. Varied reactions to the crack powder reform work of the senate judiciary committee. Oct 02, 2007 the disparity between crack cocaine and powder cocaine penalties. First step applies to conviction for crack and powder cocaine. Since booker, some courts have concluded that although the guidelines treat 1 gram of crack like 100 grams of powder cocaine, a judge who does not believe that crack cocaine is 100 times worse than powder. First step applies to conviction for crack and powder. The difference between crack cocaine and powder cocaine powder cocaine is made from coca paste, which is derived from the leaves of the coca plant. Prior to the enactment of the fsa, it took 100 times as much powder cocaine as crack cocaine to receive the same five, 10, or 20year mandatory minimum prison term. Cracked justice in august 2010 president barack obama signed the fair sentencing act fsa, historic legislation that reduced the quantitybased sentencing differential between federal crack and powder cocaine convictions that resulted in significant racial disparities and excessive penalties. The 100to1 disparity results in overly harsh sentences for crack offenders and produces a racial disparity in sentencing, as 80% of those convicted of crack offenses are black. Walton presented to the united states sentencing commission on november 14, 2006, on sentencing disparity for crack and powder cocaine offenses thank you for affording me the opportunity to appear before you today on behalf of the judicial conference of the united states criminal law committee.
Following the 1986 cocaineinduced death of university of maryland basketball star len bias, congress passed the antidrug abuse act of 1986, a mandatory minimum sentencing statute for first offense narcotic. Omnibus violent crime control and law enforcement act, the u. This disparity between crack and powder cocaine was driven by fear, instead of by research, of the intensity and perceived dangers of crack. Even former dea head and enthusiastic drug warrior asa hutchinson had little good to say about the crack powder cocaine sentencing disparity. Ginsburg noted the trial judge honed in on the particular circumstances of kimbroughs case and accorded weight to reports by the u. This arbitrary and discriminatory disparity between powder and crack cocaine implicates the section 3553a2a factors. The reform s reduce the sentencing disparity between powder and crack cocaine quantities from 100to1 to 18to1, and eliminate mandatory sentences for possession of small amounts of crack. Prior to reform the state distinguished between crack and powder at a ratio of 56. How an early biden crime bill created the sentencing. Aug 03, 2010 data show racial disparity in crack sentencing.
950 974 382 857 1181 1459 577 229 381 816 181 202 1038 1056 269 228 1154 417 155 1156 1046 127 760 51 566 877 675 496 149 575 460 193 867 367 336